Comments on: The Role of the Artist http://catskillcottageseed.com/2009/07/15/the-role-of-the-artist/ Positioning within the Imaginal Mon, 16 Apr 2012 18:04:27 -0400 http://wordpress.org/?v=2.9 hourly 1 By: ccseed http://catskillcottageseed.com/2009/07/15/the-role-of-the-artist/comment-page-1/#comment-7376 ccseed Tue, 21 Jul 2009 21:41:07 +0000 http://catskillcottageseed.com/?p=2530#comment-7376 Great contribution here Matt. In the end it's a bit paradoxical, as<br />the greatest work tends to be pretty accessible to the masses, or we<br />find that the masses catch up to it in a generation or two. I think<br />your call for depth hits it square on. The broad byways are designed<br />in many ways to keep the masses from the depth, and Jung in his<br />religious studies on this same issue makes it quite explicit that this<br />is appropriate and absolutely necessary... Great contribution here Matt. In the end it's a bit paradoxical, as
the greatest work tends to be pretty accessible to the masses, or we
find that the masses catch up to it in a generation or two. I think
your call for depth hits it square on. The broad byways are designed
in many ways to keep the masses from the depth, and Jung in his
religious studies on this same issue makes it quite explicit that this
is appropriate and absolutely necessary…

]]> By: Matt Searles http://catskillcottageseed.com/2009/07/15/the-role-of-the-artist/comment-page-1/#comment-7371 Matt Searles Tue, 21 Jul 2009 18:22:20 +0000 http://catskillcottageseed.com/?p=2530#comment-7371 Lately I find myself.. an artist desperate in his search for the broad highways... I've spent so much time on the back ways that I've never really had a good look at the broad highways! I must say its the oddest of feelings.. For one thing I don't know if I can even function on the broad highway.. while at the same time, possessed by an insecurity, I wonder if I need to take the highway.. and I'm insecure about.. what value the stuff I found in the back ways might find on the highways.. will my gold turn to ash? I understand Jung received a lot of criticism for his thoughts on the Arts.. that he wasn't real good in this area.. But I think that perhaps the critics might not have understood Jung deeply enough.. I have this experience often as well.. of the posers in Art.. or sometimes its not so much a thing of the poser as feeling.. sorry for there small spirits.. wondering if they even bother to really work at it.. I don't have an issue with an artist seeing a market.. and being like "ok, I need to paint pretty flowers and like.. light houses.. cause that's what the tourists are buying.." Where I do find the problem is when you don't take that as an opportunity for something more.. or.. when you get to a place where it's all nice and safe.. and for the sake of safety don't venture further out. Lately I find myself.. an artist desperate in his search for the broad highways… I've spent so much time on the back ways that I've never really had a good look at the broad highways!

I must say its the oddest of feelings.. For one thing I don't know if I can even function on the broad highway.. while at the same time, possessed by an insecurity, I wonder if I need to take the highway.. and I'm insecure about.. what value the stuff I found in the back ways might find on the highways.. will my gold turn to ash?

I understand Jung received a lot of criticism for his thoughts on the Arts.. that he wasn't real good in this area.. But I think that perhaps the critics might not have understood Jung deeply enough..

I have this experience often as well.. of the posers in Art.. or sometimes its not so much a thing of the poser as feeling.. sorry for there small spirits.. wondering if they even bother to really work at it.. I don't have an issue with an artist seeing a market.. and being like "ok, I need to paint pretty flowers and like.. light houses.. cause that's what the tourists are buying.." Where I do find the problem is when you don't take that as an opportunity for something more.. or.. when you get to a place where it's all nice and safe.. and for the sake of safety don't venture further out.

]]> By: ccseed http://catskillcottageseed.com/2009/07/15/the-role-of-the-artist/comment-page-1/#comment-7340 ccseed Sat, 18 Jul 2009 14:38:54 +0000 http://catskillcottageseed.com/?p=2530#comment-7340 I think the point I am trying to bring out is that the artist finds his work in the back alleys as Jung noted, not along the broad highways. I think the point I am trying to bring out is that the artist finds his work in the back alleys as Jung noted, not along the broad highways.

]]> By: Sid Parham http://catskillcottageseed.com/2009/07/15/the-role-of-the-artist/comment-page-1/#comment-7333 Sid Parham Fri, 17 Jul 2009 10:42:49 +0000 http://catskillcottageseed.com/?p=2530#comment-7333 Psychologist, Guy says artist you say artwork, The value of a Rubens may depend on the artist, but an observer can find it beautiful with no knowledge of who Rubens was, The role of the artist is a question asked by a society who values money and acheivement over beauty. Yeats may want us to bekieve we cannt "tell the dancer from the dance," but if in fact we can. Yeats and othe rmoderns tried to create an art that required you know something of the artist to appreciate it. In large measure they fail. "When you are old and Grey and full of sleep," is a beautiful poen and you need not have any knowledge of Maude Gonne to appreciate it. Psychologist, Guy says artist you say artwork, The value of a Rubens may depend on the artist, but an observer can find it beautiful with no knowledge of who Rubens was, The role of the artist is a question asked by a society who values money and acheivement over beauty. Yeats may want us to bekieve we cannt "tell the dancer from the dance," but if in fact we can. Yeats and othe rmoderns tried to create an art that required you know something of the artist to appreciate it. In large measure they fail. "When you are old and Grey and full of sleep," is a beautiful poen and you need not have any knowledge of Maude Gonne to appreciate it.

]]> By: ccseed http://catskillcottageseed.com/2009/07/15/the-role-of-the-artist/comment-page-1/#comment-7317 ccseed Wed, 15 Jul 2009 19:12:06 +0000 http://catskillcottageseed.com/?p=2530#comment-7317 Hmm...where I beg to differ is that the artwork in isolation is irrelevant, which is why the work continues to persist after the artist passes away... The tell tale sign of the group I'm lampooning a bit is that the work did not back up all the posturing. Hmm…where I beg to differ is that the artwork in isolation is irrelevant, which is why the work continues to persist after the artist passes away…

The tell tale sign of the group I'm lampooning a bit is that the work did not back up all the posturing.

]]> By: Just Some Guy http://catskillcottageseed.com/2009/07/15/the-role-of-the-artist/comment-page-1/#comment-7316 Just Some Guy Wed, 15 Jul 2009 18:32:34 +0000 http://catskillcottageseed.com/?p=2530#comment-7316 True, but another facet of what Jung alludes to is the dual nature of this beast sometimes called "Art": In isolation, the artist is irrelevant. To an utterly external observer (say, an alien!) what we think of as what an artist "does" might well appear to be little other than dirty cloth, bent and ruined metal, clay, paper. Striving so to find a voice, we can't help but overlook the fact that the *language* we will speak with it is in fact already defined. Perhaps it's a function of this language (as an organism) that it is often tossed about frivolously. Perhaps we could think of all the pomp, posture and self-indulgence that is the "Art Scene" as a sort of small talk. It's difficult to resist a quote from Goth pioneers Bauhaus: "Small talk stinks." :) True, but another facet of what Jung alludes to is the dual nature of this beast sometimes called "Art": In isolation, the artist is irrelevant. To an utterly external observer (say, an alien!) what we think of as what an artist "does" might well appear to be little other than dirty cloth, bent and ruined metal, clay, paper. Striving so to find a voice, we can't help but overlook the fact that the *language* we will speak with it is in fact already defined. Perhaps it's a function of this language (as an organism) that it is often tossed about frivolously. Perhaps we could think of all the pomp, posture and self-indulgence that is the "Art Scene" as a sort of small talk.

It's difficult to resist a quote from Goth pioneers Bauhaus: "Small talk stinks." :)

]]>